Policy and
 Outreach

S.T.O.P. Policy Statements
Comments, Speeches, & Testimony
Newsletters
Press Releases
Media


S.T.O.P. is Citizen Supported.
Your help is critical to continue the fight against foodborne disease.




 

_\|/_
 

Public Comments

Good afternoon, my name is Don Knowles. I’m here for a different reason than probably all of you. I am here to advocate the development of an animal identification system that includes the purpose of preventing foodborne illness in people. I represent an organization called S. T. O. P. - Safe Tables Our Priority - which was formed in the aftermath of the 1993 E. coli O157:H7 outbreak in the Northwest associated with Jack-in-the-Box hamburgers. S.T.O.P. has become a key player in facilitating the first meat and poultry inspection reforms in over 90 years; reforms that have included microbial testing for animal fecal contamination.

I am also here to represent consumers and victims of foodborne illness. My son, Tyler, who is now 18 is such a victim. Eleven years ago this month, Tyler’s young, healthy body was attacked by a vicious pathogen contained in a ground beef patty. The E. coli bacterial illness ultimately evolved into a life-threatening condition called Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome. His kidneys stopped working completely resulting in a month’s stay in the Denver Children’s Hospital during which he received several blood transfusions and many kidney dialysis treatments. Tyler survived; others have not been so fortunate. Our family lived through a horror I hope none of you ever have to experience. It dramatically changed our lives.
Foodborne illness is a serious health problem in our country. Over 76 million cases of foodborne illness occur in this country every year, sending over 300,000 Americans to the hospital, and causing over 5000 deaths. To put that in perspective, that is more deaths each year than the terrorist attacks on 9/11. Literally millions annually suffer long-term illnesses as a result. Many of these illnesses come directly from meat products contaminated with pathogens at the time consumers purchase them at the grocery store.

I feel that an animal identification system should be implemented with not only the goal of preventing illness in animals, which is well and good, but also have the authority to trace animals that arrive at the slaughterhouse loaded with human pathogens. A 2003 report by a National Academy of Sciences committee concluded that the level of contamination on and in animals coming to slaughter is tied to contamination levels in meat. The committee urged government to monitor contamination of incoming animals and take steps to mitigate the problem. The committee also noted that other countries have achieved dramatic declines in certain pathogens by using microbial monitoring to drive farm-based control efforts.

An animal identification system must be mandatory, uniform, and administered by the federal government. It must also include enforcement provisions to penalize those who choose not to abide by the rules. If the system is not mandatory, those who choose not to participate will not only continue to contribute to animal and human health problems, but will have an economic advantage over those who pony up the funds to do it right. Uniformity with federal administration is also key to ensuring that all producers play under the same rules and that no one gains an economic advantage while reducing human health protection.

I urge you to develop an animal tracking system that includes the provisions to trace back to the farm animals that come to slaughter with high levels of human pathogens. To implement anything else will be a shameful loss of a unique opportunity to exponentially reduce foodborne disease - and a kick in the teeth for the thousands of victims of E. coli, Salmonella, Campylobacter and other devastating meat-borne diseases who are forced to watch as government pours millions of dollars building a bridge that reaches only halfway across the chasm of foodborne disease.

 

 

 

Safe Tables Our Priority 
P.O. Box 4352 
Burlington, VT 05406

Media & Business (802) 863-0555 
Victims & Victims' Families (800) 350-S.T.O.P. 
 
Send e-mail to: